Fri 29 Oct 2027
Community Development, Pittsburgh-Style
Posted by Frank under Classes, Pittsburgh Development
No Comments
Another interesting History of Pittsburgh class–Dr. Lemley’s teaching style is very different than any other professor I’ve had, especially in history classes. Instead of teaching in a time line fashion, he’s always jumping back and forth between early Pittsburgh, steel-era Pittsburgh, back to Pittsburgh around World War 1, and then to Pittsburgh in the late 20th/early 21st century. In some ways it’s confusing because you never know where you’re going to go next, but it also is a really good way to draw connections between the past and the present, which I think is what history is really all about.
We just had a class on community development, and it was fascinating. For a long time in Pittsburgh, going back to when the original Civic Arena was built and most of the lower hill was destroyed, I mean “developed,” large-scale projects took a top-down approach. The mayor or influential council members would work out big deals to do big things, and almost always completely ignore the people on the ground who said it was a bad idea. There were actual protests organized when the Arena was originally being built in the late 1950s, the people voted against the stadiums being built and they were built anyway in the late 1990s, and the whole Fifth-Forbes corridor development has been a fiasco ever since it was first conceived decades ago. It’s an interesting trend, and one that didn’t stop until the early 20-teens.
So that was the lesson, and then we had a discussion/debate in class. The question was: “What happened in the early 20-teens to change this historical trend?” People went back and forth, pulling out little bits of information and trying to make big conclusions out of them. By the end of class, however, what we realized is that there wasn’t one “thing” that happened to change the trend. It just changed. It’s almost as if the collective consciousness of Pittsburgh finally woke up and said, “Enough of this bullshit–the politicians have no idea what’s going on, so why do we depend on them?” People started doing their own community development–there was an explosion of small local businesses, neighborhood groups became very active and influential, and Students for a Sustainable Pittsburgh gained traction and made these issues big, visible, and most importantly, seem solvable. After a while, new blood started coming into local politics, and the old ways just vanished.
Change happened right before everyone’s eyes, and no one really knew it was happening. It seems like the lesson here is that real change doesn’t begin with a ribbon-cutting ceremony, it starts with people doing little things, and then letting those little things build on other little things until all you can do is look back and say, “Wow.”

